December 22, 2010

Book Vs. Movie: Surrogates

The Book:

written by Robert Vendetti
illustrated by Brett Weidele
published by Top Shelf Productions (2006)

The Movie:
starring Bruce Willis, Rhada Mitchelle, Ving Rhames, and James Cromwell
directed by Jonathan Mostow
screenplay by John Brancato & Michael Ferris
released by Touchstone Pictures (2009)

I read and reviewed the two graphic novels (The Surrogates and The Surrogates: Flesh and Bone) by Robert Vendetti and Brett Weidele back in the spring. So when I finally got around to watching the film adaptation, I thought I'd do a little contrast-and-compare.

In the graphic novel, the lead detective is a kind of hard-boiled kind of cop that epitomizes the gritty art style that defines him. Bruce Willis, however, looks very polished as that character. Almost cosmopolitan, dare I say. Granted, he's classic hard-nosed Bruce when his surrogate is damaged and he has to continue his investigation by walking the streets the old fashioned way. Personally, I thought his surrogate looked a bit like his psychiatrist character from The Sixth Sense, while his real-life counterpart looked like an even more grizzled version of Die Hard's McClain.

The story goes that a couple of people have died--murdered--while operating surrogates, which is something that has loss been deemed impossible by everyone in the know. So, the cops have to not only work with the monopoly that manufactures surrogates in order to find out how it's possible to kill someone via a surrogate--a notion they dismiss outright--and deal with the anti-surrogate movement that is where their lead suspect resides.

The book tackles a lot of the philosophical questions related to living life through an avater. Things like vanity, reclusiveness, classism, racism, and a slew of other issues are approached at different points. In the movie, however, the focus really leans towards the mystery and the potential conspiracy behind who would want to sew seeds of doubt concerning the security of surrogates. On the other hand, the action scenes are so much more potent on screen than on paper. Seeing man versus man-in-surrogates was a sight to behold.

Winner: The Book. I say check out the book first, especially if you're interested in those underlying questions about a technology that would allow you to look how you've always dreamed (if you have the cash), and live life while sitting in a pod and treating real life like an elaborate video-game. If you just want some sci-fi action with cool special effects and a couple of explosions, then go with the movie, as it has its own benefits.


  1. This is, unfortunately, another case where I've seen the movie but have not read the book.

    I remember enjoying the movie to a point. I'll have to check the book out now.

  2. The books are worth looking at if the movie left you wanting more.